Should I Turn Sebastian In For Killing His Uncle? Unpacking That Tough Hogwarts Legacy Choice
Deciding what to do with Sebastian Sallow after he uses the Unforgivable Curse on his uncle is, honestly, one of the most agonizing choices you'll face in Hogwarts Legacy. This isn't just about game mechanics; it's a deep dive into loyalty, justice, and the consequences of dark magic. Many players find themselves wrestling with this very question, wondering what the right path truly is. It's a moment that really makes you think about the kind of wizard or witch you want to be in this magical world.
You've seen Sebastian's journey, his desperate attempts to help his sister, Anne, and the lengths he's willing to go to ease her suffering. His actions, while extreme, stem from a place of deep love and frustration. Yet, the use of Avada Kedavra, the Killing Curse, is a line that, for many, simply cannot be crossed. It's a dark deed, no matter the motivation, and that, is that, a fact you can't ignore.
So, you're here because you're standing at that crossroads, trying to figure out if turning Sebastian in for killing his uncle is the right move for you and your game experience. We get it; this decision carries a lot of weight, and there are real impacts on the story and the characters you've come to know. We'll explore what happens either way, helping you weigh the scales of justice and friendship in your own unique way, you know?
Table of Contents
- The Heart of the Matter: Sebastian's Desperate Act
- Why He Did It: Sebastian's Motivations and Guilt
- The Unforgivable Curse and Its Weight
- What Happens If You Turn Sebastian In?
- What Happens If You Protect Sebastian?
- Making Your Personal Choice
- Frequently Asked Questions About the Sebastian Decision
The Heart of the Matter: Sebastian's Desperate Act
By the time you're asking "Should I turn Sebastian in for killing his uncle?", you've already witnessed the pivotal moment. Sebastian Sallow, a fellow Slytherin student and a friend you've shared many adventures with, uses the Killing Curse, Avada Kedavra, on his uncle, Solomon. This event is a fixed part of the game's storyline; you can't actually stop him from doing it, no matter what you try. It's a rather dramatic turning point, wouldn't you say?
His uncle, Solomon, had, in a way, put him through quite a bit of hardship, and Sebastian was deeply entrenched in finding a cure for Anne. This whole situation, his obsession with dark magic, and his uncle's constant interference, led to a showdown. In that intense moment, Sebastian lashed out, using the unforgivable curse. It's a very charged scene, and you're right there to see it unfold, almost feeling the raw emotion.
Why He Did It: Sebastian's Motivations and Guilt
Sebastian's actions, while extreme, are rooted in his desire to take Anne's pain away. He genuinely loves his sister and feels a tremendous burden to find a cure for her mysterious affliction. This desperation, combined with the pressure from his uncle, pushed him to the brink. When you talk to Sebastian after the event, it's clear he's feeling immense guilt. He didn't, in fact, mean to kill his uncle; the situation just escalated beyond what he intended, which is something you can probably understand, right?
He was so focused on his goal, so consumed by the need to help Anne, that his judgment became clouded by the dark magic he was exploring. At the time of the murder, he probably felt a twisted sense of justification, given all the "crap" his uncle had put him through. But the true weight of his decision, the full horror of what he'd done, likely didn't kick in until much later, after he had time to process everything. He's a character dealing with a lot, and that's pretty clear.
The Unforgivable Curse and Its Weight
Avada Kedavra, the Killing Curse, is one of the three Unforgivable Curses for a very good reason. Its use carries severe consequences in the wizarding world, often leading to a life sentence in Azkaban. Sebastian's use of it isn't just a plot point; it's a profound moral breach. For many players, seeing him use such a dark spell, especially on a family member, makes the decision to turn him in feel like a moral imperative. It's a very serious act, after all.
The game itself presents this as a huge deal. Your decision isn't just about Sebastian; it's also about what you, as a player, believe is right. Do you condone the use of such a curse, even under extreme duress, or do you uphold the strict laws of the wizarding world? This choice, in a way, helps define your character's own moral compass within the game's story, so it's a bit more than just a simple button press.
What Happens If You Turn Sebastian In?
If you decide to turn Sebastian in for killing his uncle, you're essentially sending him away for life. He is gone for the rest of the game, plain and simple. This means you lose him as a companion and a quest giver. For many players, this can feel like a pretty big loss, especially if you've grown attached to his character throughout your adventures. It's a final decision, you know?
The Impact on the Story
Without Sebastian, the game's ending, particularly the final acts and character interactions, can feel a bit less complete. His storyline, his struggles, and his potential for remorse are cut short. The narrative loses a significant character arc, and some players might find the overall experience feels "flat" without his presence. It's almost as if a piece of the story goes missing, which can be a little disappointing for those who enjoyed his role.
Missing Out on Dark Magic?
One practical consequence of turning Sebastian in is that you might miss your chance to learn the Killing Curse, Avada Kedavra, from him. If you haven't learned the three Unforgivable Curses by this point, and you were hoping to, turning him in means you won't get that opportunity. Some players regret this later, feeling they missed a bit of the game's full experience by not having access to all spells. So, that's something to consider, especially if you're a completionist, or just like having all the options.
What Happens If You Protect Sebastian?
Choosing to protect Sebastian, despite his use of the Unforgivable Curse, keeps him in the game. This path allows his storyline to continue, and he remains a part of your adventures. It's a choice that shows immense loyalty, or perhaps, a belief in second chances and the possibility of redemption. This decision, too, has its own set of unique consequences and implications for the story, and your relationships with other characters, very much so.
Keeping Him Around
By protecting Sebastian, he stays with you for the remainder of the game. This means his character arc can progress further, and you get to see him grapple with the weight of his actions. It provides him with the chance at remorse for what he did, allowing for a more complete emotional journey for his character. Many players find this path more satisfying from a narrative perspective, as it lets you see the full scope of his personal struggles, which is quite compelling.
Ominis and Anne
If you protect Sebastian, you'll also need to convince Ominis Gaunt that Sebastian must stay with Anne. Ominis is, understandably, very upset by Sebastian's actions, and convincing him requires some effort. This adds another layer of complexity to the relationships within the game, forcing you to engage with the fallout of Sebastian's choices on his closest friends and family. It's a rather delicate situation, and your words truly matter here.
Learning Avada Kedavra
A significant practical benefit for some players who choose not to turn Sebastian in is the opportunity to learn the Killing Curse, Avada Kedavra, from him. If you want to learn this powerful, dark spell, you should get it from him before making any final decisions about his fate. For those who enjoy exploring all aspects of the game's magic, even the forbidden kind, this is a key consideration. It's almost like a perk, in a way, for sticking by him.
Making Your Personal Choice
The question "Should I turn Sebastian in for killing his uncle?" isn't about a right or wrong answer dictated by the game. It's about your own moral compass and what kind of story you want to experience. Do you prioritize justice and the rules of the wizarding world, even if it means losing a friend? Or do you value loyalty, understanding, and the possibility of redemption, even when a grave wrong has been committed? This is your adventure, after all, and your decisions shape it, very much so.
Think about how you feel about Sebastian's motivations, his guilt, and the severity of his actions. Consider the consequences for the game's ending and your access to certain spells. Ultimately, the best choice is the one that feels most authentic to your own character and play style. There's no single answer that fits everyone, and that's what makes this particular decision so memorable and impactful in Hogwarts Legacy. It's your story to write, you know?
Learn more about game choices on our site. And if you're curious about other difficult decisions, you can link to this page here for more insights.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Sebastian Decision
What happens if I don't turn Sebastian in?
If you choose not to turn Sebastian in, he remains a part of your game experience. You can continue his storyline, see his character grapple with his actions, and even learn the Unforgivable Curse, Avada Kedavra, from him if you haven't already. You will also need to convince Ominis that Sebastian should stay with Anne, which adds another layer to their relationships, naturally.
Can you stop Sebastian from killing his uncle in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, there is no way to prevent Sebastian from killing his uncle in Hogwarts Legacy. This event is a fixed part of the main storyline, and your character is a witness to it, not an intervener in that specific moment. The choice you make comes after the fact, regarding whether to report him, so it's a bit of a set event.
Does turning Sebastian in affect the game's ending?
Yes, turning Sebastian in for killing his uncle does affect the game's ending, or at least the feeling of it. Without Sebastian present, his character arc is cut short, and some players feel the overall narrative concludes in a way that's a bit less satisfying or "flat." His absence removes a significant character from the final stages of the story, which can change the emotional impact, obviously.
Bolans man denies killing his uncle - Antigua Observer Newspaper
Uncle charged with killing nephew in Queens stabbing | amNewYork
Syracuse man convicted twice of killing his uncle tells judge I didn’t
