Understanding "Who Has Custody Of Alana?": A Grammatical Deep Dive
The question "Who has custody of Alana?" is one that often piques public interest, especially concerning public figures. However, beyond the specific individual involved, this seemingly simple query offers a fascinating opportunity to explore some fundamental rules of English grammar, particularly the correct usage of "has" versus "have." While the legal specifics of Alana's custody are outside the scope of this discussion, understanding why the question is phrased with "has" rather than "have" provides valuable insight into proper English usage.
The Core Question: Why "Who Has Custody?"
Let's break down the grammar of "Who has custody of Alana?" The key lies in understanding subject-verb agreement, especially when the subject is a singular pronoun like "who" in this context. As a general rule, we use "has" with singular subjects, and "have" with plural subjects or the pronouns "I," "you," "we," and "they."
Consider the following:
- He has a cell phone. (Singular subject "He")
- She has a book. (Singular subject "She")
- It has four legs. (Singular subject "It")
In the question "Who has custody?", "who" acts as a singular pronoun referring to a single, unidentified person. Therefore, the verb that follows must agree with this singular subject, which is "has." The answer in both instances, if we were to replace "who" with a specific singular person, would correctly use "has" (e.g., "Her sister has custody").
This is why the phrase "Who has custody?" is grammatically sound. It aligns with the rule that "has" is used with singular subjects, and "who," when referring to a single individual, falls into this category. The question essentially asks, "Which singular person possesses or holds custody?"
Navigating "Have" vs. "Has": Common Pitfalls
While "has" is correct in "Who has custody?", there are many instances where "have" is the appropriate choice, and confusing the two is a common grammatical error. The "Data Kalimat" highlights several important distinctions.
The "Do/Does" Rule
One of the most frequent mistakes occurs when questions or negative statements begin with "do" or "does." The rule is clear: it is ungrammatical to use "has" in questions that begin with "do" or "does." In these types of questions, the verb "do" is conjugated based on the subject, and the main verb reverts to its base form, which is "have."
Let's look at an example provided:
- She doesn't has a book. (Incorrect)
- She doesn't have a book. (Correct)
Why is the first sentence wrong? Because "does" is already conjugated for the singular subject "she." The main verb that follows ("have") must be in its infinitive form. The same principle applies to questions:
- Does she has a car? (Incorrect)
- Does she have a car? (Correct)
So, while "Who has custody?" is correct because "who" is the subject directly performing the action (or possessing the state), a question like "Does Alana have custody?" would be correct, not "Does Alana has custody?"
"Have" as a Main Verb in the Progressive Form
Another point of confusion arises with the progressive (or continuous) tense. You don't use the word "have" as a main verb in the progressive to talk about things you own or possess. For instance, you wouldn't say "I am having a car" to mean "I own a car." The correct sentence is "I have a car." However, you can use "have" in the progressive when it refers to experiences or actions, such as "I am having a good time" or "She is having lunch." This distinction is crucial for clear communication.
"Has" as Auxiliary vs. Main Verb
The word "has" can function in two primary ways in a sentence: as a main verb or as an auxiliary (helping) verb. Understanding this difference is key to mastering its usage.
"Has" as a Main Verb (Possession/Ownership)
When "has" is the main verb, it typically indicates possession, ownership, or a characteristic. This is the case in our original question, "Who has custody?" Here, "has" denotes possession of the legal right or responsibility of custody.
Examples:
- He has a cell phone. (Possession)
- She has blue eyes. (Characteristic)
- The house has three bedrooms. (Possession/Characteristic)
"Has" as an Auxiliary Verb (Perfect Tenses)
When "has" acts as an auxiliary verb, it combines with a past participle to form perfect tenses, indicating an action completed at some point or continuing up to the present. The "Data Kalimat" provides examples of this:
- He has completed his work. (Present perfect tense)
- The idea has deleted. (Incorrect - should be passive voice)
- The idea has been deleted. (Correct - present perfect passive)
The difference between "the idea has deleted" and "the idea has been deleted" is significant. The first implies the idea itself performed the action of deleting, which is illogical. The second, using "has been" (a form of "has" as an auxiliary with "been"), correctly indicates that the idea was the recipient of the action (it was deleted by someone or something else).
Another common auxiliary use is with "got," as in "It has got four legs." Here, "has got" functions similarly to "has" for possession, with "has" being the auxiliary verb in this common informal construction.
Comparing "Is" and "Has"
The "Data Kalimat" also touches on the confusion between "is" and "has" in certain contexts, like "Tea is come" vs. "Tea has come." This highlights the difference between the simple present/passive voice ("is ready") and the present perfect tense ("has come").
- Tea is ready. (State of being, simple present/adjective)
- Tea has come. (Action completed, present perfect)
- He is come back. (Less common, archaic, or regional)
- He has come back. (Correct and common present perfect)
In these examples, "has" is used to form the present perfect tense, indicating an action that started in the past and has a connection to the present. "Is" describes a current state or is part of a passive construction.
Why This Grammatical Understanding Matters
Understanding the nuances of "has" and "have" is not merely an academic exercise. It's fundamental to clear, precise communication in English. Whether you're asking about who possesses an item, who has completed a task, or indeed, who has legal custody of an individual, using the correct verb form ensures your message is understood as intended.
The distinction between "has" for singular subjects and "have" for plural/specific pronouns, the rule regarding "do/does" questions, and the different roles of "has" as a main or auxiliary verb are all pillars of correct English grammar. Mastering these allows you to confidently construct sentences and questions, avoiding common errors and enhancing your overall fluency.
Summary
In summary, the question "Who has custody of Alana?" is grammatically correct because "who" acts as a singular subject, requiring the singular verb "has." This aligns with the rule that "has" is used with singular nouns and pronouns (he, she, it). Conversely, "have" is used with plural subjects (we, they) and the pronouns I and you. It's crucial to remember that when questions or negative statements use "do" or "does," the main verb always reverts to its base form "have" (e.g., "She doesn't have a book," not "She doesn't has a book"). Furthermore, "has" can function as a main verb indicating possession (e.g., "He has a cell phone") or as an auxiliary verb forming perfect tenses (e.g., "He has completed his work"). Understanding these distinctions is key to accurate and effective communication in English.
Alana Francis- The Body Shop at Home- Independent Consultant | Port
St. Jude Possibilities - Alana | Alana has big plans for the future now
Alana Lockett-Hartley, Agent | Travel By Design
